DBR vs EMDR: What’s the Difference, and How Do You Choose?
Many people exploring trauma therapy eventually come across both Deep Brain Reorienting (DBR) and Eye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing (EMDR). It is common to search for “DBR vs EMDR” or “EMDR vs DBR” when trying to understand which approach might be the right fit. There can be many reasons they might have started this search, including shutting down, becoming defensive, or feeling overwhelmed in relationships.
Both DBR and EMDR are established approaches used to work with trauma. They share some similarities, but they are based on different understandings of how traumatic experience is processed, and they can feel quite different in practice.
What is the difference between DBR and EMDR?
At a broad level, both DBR and EMDR aim to help the nervous system process experiences that remain unresolved. EMDR works by helping the brain reprocess distressing memories using bilateral stimulation, such as guided eye movements, while aspects of the experience are held in awareness. The focus is usually on a specific memory, image or belief, and the process can involve moving attention between past experiences and present awareness. Deep Brain Reorienting (DBR) works more slowly and focuses on the earliest responses to perceived threat which are organised in the brainstem. In addition, DBR can begin from different starting points, sometimes including aspects of a narrative, but the emphasis is less on the story itself and more on the body’s initial responses, which are then followed as they unfold.
In simple terms, EMDR often begins with the memory, whereas DBR often begins with the body’s initial response to threat, which does not neccesarily need to be the memory, or the ‘original story’.
How do DBR and EMDR feel in practice?
People often wonder “is EMDR overwhelming?” or how DBR compares experientially. Experiences vary, and much depends on the therapist and the individual. EMDR can at times feel more active or structured, particularly when working directly with specific memories. DBR tends to move more gradually, following the nervous system at a slower pace. Some people find this allows difficult material to emerge in a more contained way, particularly where there is a history of dissociation or overwhelm. At the same time, both approaches can be carefully paced and adapted. Different therapists work in different ways, and each client is unique.
Which therapy is better for trauma: EMDR or DBR?
People often ask “is DBR better than EMDR?” or “which therapy is better for trauma, EMDR or DBR?” There is no single answer. EMDR has been around for longer, and so it has a larger evidence base and is widely used across many settings. Dr Frank Corrigan, a former NHS Consultant Psychiatrist with over 30 years’ experience, developed DBR through clinical practice and research into the brain-based processes underlying trauma. Therapists are now increasingly exploring DBR to work more directly with early shock and attachment responses. Research into DBR is still developing. A 2023 randomised controlled trial found early evidence that it may offer an effective and well-tolerated treatment for PTSD, with further studies ongoing. As with many newer approaches, the evidence base is growing. Alongside this, therapists and clients report meaningful changes taking place, with clients finding symptoms easing or shifting. Ultimately, what matters most is not which therapy is “better” in general, but which approach fits the individual, and how the therapist works with it.
EMDR, DBR, and other body-based approaches
You may also come across broader terms such as somatic therapy, Sensorimotor Psychotherapy, or body-based psychotherapy. EMDR and DBR are within a wider movement that recognises the role of the body and nervous system in trauma. If you are searching for “EMDR or somatic therapy”, it is often more useful to think less in terms of strict categories and more in terms of finding a therapist you resonate with. Although EMDR and DBR follow specific protocols, they sit within a broader understanding of how the brain, body, and nervous system are involved in trauma and its resolution.
How to choose between DBR and EMDR
If you are deciding between DBR and EMDR, it can be useful to consider:
- whether you prefer a more structured or a more exploratory process
- how you tend to respond to intensity or emotional activation
- whether previous therapy has felt overwhelming or not quite reached the core of the issue
- the experience and approach of the therapist
It can be less about choosing the “right” model in theory and more about finding an approach and a therapist that feels workable for you.
A note on how I work
In my own practice, I primarily work using Deep Brain Reorienting (DBR) alongside other body-based approaches. This reflects my experience of how certain patterns, particularly those linked to early attachment and shock, can be accessed and processed. At the same time, EMDR remains a widely used and respected approach, and others may work with it differently or have a different perspective.
Get in touch
Are you interested in learning more? Contact me for further information and availability.
Share this article
Know someone who might benefit from this article? Share it by clicking the links below.